Federal Funding Restrictions, Academic Research, and the First Amendment
Academic research is integral to discovery, innovation, and economic prosperity. The funding that sustains this enterprise is also indispensable to American universities’ financial sustainability. Seizing on universities’ reliance on this funding, the Trump Administration has leveraged the federal government’s position as the leading funder of academic research to make its mark on America’s higher education system. Specifically targeting diversity, equity, and inclusion, environmental justice, and progressive notions of gender identity, the Trump Administration has revoked research funding and instructed federal agencies to decline to fund any research that touches on ideas it disfavors. It has also threatened to broadly strip funding from universities that promote diversity, equity, and inclusion in curriculum, instruction, and programming. Given the significant amounts of money at stake—as much as billions of dollars for the wealthiest universities—higher education institutions and researchers are understandably feeling the chill. But some universities and academics have fought back successfully, prevailing in court challenges to the Trump Administration’s executive orders, agency policies, and grant terminations.
This Essay will assess the role the First Amendment is playing in the disputes between the Trump administration and higher education. Speech doctrine unfortunately does not provide easy answers. The Trump Administration’s restrictions on academic research fall within a doctrinal quagmire of competing and conflicting rules. Implicated in these disputes are the unconstitutional conditions doctrine, government speech, subsidized speech, academic freedom, coercion, and viewpoint discrimination. This Essay clarifies how these doctrines fit together and provides advice to universities and academics on how to most effectively repel the federal government’s overreach. Ultimately, it concludes that most of the Trump Administration’s threats to and conditions on federal funding in the higher education context violate the First Amendment.
Continue reading Federal Funding Restrictions, Academic Research, and the First Amendment.